Syrah and Pinot Noir are two of the most loved red wines in the world, and they sit at very different points on the flavor map. Pinot Noir is light, perfumed and silky. Syrah is darker, peppery and fuller in the glass. If you have ever stood in a wine shop wondering which bottle to take home, this guide explains how the two compare on body, tannin, flavor, regions and food, so you can choose with confidence.
The short answer
- Pinot Noir: light to medium body, soft tannins, bright acidity, flavors of red cherry, cranberry, raspberry and earth.
- Syrah: medium to full body, firmer tannins, flavors of blackberry, black pepper, smoke and savory notes.
- Same grape as Shiraz: Syrah is the French name, and Australia and South Africa often use Shiraz on the label.
- Best for: Pinot suits delicate dishes and relaxed sipping. Syrah suits grilled food and cold evenings.
Body and tannin
Body is how heavy a wine feels in your mouth. Pinot Noir is one of the lightest red wines because its grapes have thin skins. Thin skins give less color and fewer tannins, which is why a glass of Pinot looks pale and transparent and feels smooth and soft.
Syrah has thicker skins and produces deeper color, more tannin and more weight. Tannins are the compounds that make your mouth feel slightly dry after a sip, similar to strong black tea. In Syrah they are noticeable but usually rounded, and they soften as the wine ages. If you want a deeper look at tannin in a bolder red, our guide to what Cabernet Sauvignon is covers how structure builds in a big red.
Flavor and aroma
Pinot Noir tends to smell of red fruit: cherry, strawberry, raspberry and sometimes cranberry. Aged bottles pick up savory notes such as mushroom, forest floor and dried leaves. A touch of baking spice from oak is common. The acidity is lively, which makes Pinot feel fresh and gives it a long, clean finish.
Syrah leans darker. Expect blackberry, blueberry and plum, then black pepper, smoked meat, olive, licorice and sometimes violet. The pepper note is the signature of the grape. Syrah from warm places can taste jammy and rich, while Syrah from cooler places is more peppery, lighter and more savory.
Where each grape grows
Pinot Noir is famously fussy. It likes cool climates and careful farming, and it shows the place it comes from more clearly than most grapes. Classic homes include Burgundy in France, the Willamette Valley in Oregon, the Sonoma Coast and Russian River Valley in California, and New Zealand.
Syrah is more adaptable. Its home is the Northern Rhône in France, where it makes structured, peppery wines. It also thrives in Washington State, the Central Coast of California, Chile and Australia, where it is called Shiraz and tends to be bigger and riper. Our list of Syrah recommendations for Cab and Pinot lovers includes bottles from several of these regions.
How climate changes the glass
Both grapes change character with temperature. A cool climate keeps acidity high and flavors fresh. A warm climate pushes sugar and ripeness up, which means more alcohol and darker, jammier fruit. Pinot Noir often lands in a moderate alcohol range, while Syrah usually runs a little higher. Check the label if you want a lighter wine. Alcohol level is printed on every bottle and is a quick clue to how full the wine will feel.
Food pairings
Pinot Noir is one of the most flexible food wines. Its acidity and light tannins work with roast chicken, duck, salmon, mushroom dishes and pork. It also holds up at a holiday table. If you want ideas to build a menu around it, see our top 5 pairings for Pinot Noir.
Syrah wants richer, smokier food. Think grilled steak, lamb, sausages, barbecue, roasted vegetables and hard cheeses. The pepper in the wine echoes spices in the food, and the tannins cut through fat. For a comparison with another bold red, our top 5 pairings for Cabernet Sauvignon shows how structure and food interact.
Serving temperature and storage
Serve Pinot Noir slightly cool, around the temperature of a cellar, so its fruit and acidity stay bright. Syrah is happier a bit warmer, but not at the temperature of a heated room. If a bottle feels warm, ten minutes in the refrigerator helps either wine. Syrah usually ages longer than Pinot Noir because of its tannin and structure, though many bottles of both are made to be enjoyed soon after release. For the details, read how long you can store wine.
How to choose between them
Pick Pinot Noir if you like soft, fruity reds, lighter wines, or a bottle that goes with a wide range of dishes. Pick Syrah if you want more weight, spice and a savory edge, especially with grilled or hearty food. If you cannot decide, a Syrah from a cooler region, such as the Sonoma Coast or the Northern Rhône, sits closest to Pinot Noir and is a good bridge between the two.
Price is not a reliable guide to which one you will like. Good examples of both exist at modest prices, as our roundup of affordable red wines shows. When you are buying in a shop or at a restaurant, it also helps to ask for advice, and our list of questions to ask your sommelier gives you the words to do it.
Frequently asked questions
Is Syrah sweeter than Pinot Noir?
No. Both are normally made dry, with little or no sugar left. Syrah can seem sweeter because ripe dark fruit tastes rich, and Pinot Noir can seem tart because of its acidity.
Is Syrah the same as Shiraz?
Yes. They are the same grape. Syrah is the traditional French name and is common in Europe and in cooler regions. Shiraz is the name widely used in Australia and South Africa, often for riper, fuller wines.
Which one is lighter in body?
Pinot Noir. It is one of the lightest red wines, with a pale color and softer tannins. Syrah is usually medium to full in body.
Can I drink either one with fish?
Pinot Noir is a safe choice with richer fish such as salmon or tuna. Syrah is usually too heavy for most fish, but works with grilled and smoky dishes.
Which wine is better for beginners?
Many people start with Pinot Noir because it is soft and easy to enjoy. A Syrah from a cooler region is also approachable. The best way to learn is to taste both side by side with the same food.
Keep exploring
Want more help reading a label and finding your style? Browse our Wine 101 guides for plain explanations of grapes, regions and tasting, and open the guides above to compare each style in more detail.
Planning a meal? See our full guide on what to pair with Pinot Noir.





































